My thoughts would be if Keane plays or even Godfrey we have to play 3 at the back, the defence can't scramble as well without its settled unit with Keane in a four and we need to after we commit men forward quickly. I also think Garner is wasted at the front of a midfeild three, he absolutely worked his socks off but we retain the ball far better when he and Onana are deepr as a two. If Doucoure is out play Harrison or Danjuma off the striker, Harrison has show he can manage the workload in that position. I felt taking Gana off would have been the smart move and having a more natural player in Danjuma off the striker or even going two up top, certainly better than putting McNeil on the right where he looks unhappy.
That being said we still should have won the game, pretty gutted as I would dearly love to win a cup. Lot of divvies in the crowd tonight, saw two fights nearly breaking out with self entitled chodes who think the correct response to any error is to abuse lads in the worst language.