Ronald Koeman discussion

Status
Not open for further replies.
I have the blimp on ignore, but i'm guessing it's slating Koeman after 3 games in which we have won 2 and drawn 1?

Oh dear :(

Koeman will go onto be the best manager we have had since HK, prepared to be vaulted.
 

mikeh72 said:
If we return to this debate in 3 years I'm pretty sure we'll have seen a better win % than 31% (assuming Koeman's still here). It's not too difficult to improve on.
Click to expand...



Martinez
played won drawn lost 143 61 39 43 42.7
143
won
61
drawn
39
lost
43
win % 43%


Moyes
played
518
Won
218
drawn
139
lost
161
win % 42.1



Royle
played
118
won
47
drawn
36
lost
35
win % 40%
 
BlueToff said:
Well, he has managed at Benfica and Valencia. Not exactly small clubs.

I agree though he has to prove himself with us. I do think though that the early signs are positive and I have no doubt he's the most high-profile/best manager we've appointed during my time as an Evertonian (admittedly, he's only the third manager during that time).
Click to expand...
And he was sacked from both.
 
davek said:
And he was sacked from both.
Click to expand...

Yet didn't exactly fail either. In fact I'm pretty sure he resigned from Benfica due to not winning the league - even though it was against a strong Porto side. He did however win their equivalent of the cup.

At Valencia, they were poor in the league yes, against a huge backfall of financial instability however - and that has been said many times before. And even so, they still won the Copa - so going by your logic for Martinez mate that's a huge plus.

Either way, he quite clearly learnt from his mistakes at those massive clubs (both bigger than Everton, btw) and has improved in the seven years since he was sacked from Valencia.
 

davek said:
Martinez
played won drawn lost 143 61 39 43 42.7
143
won
61
drawn
39
lost
43
win % 43%


Moyes
played
518
Won
218
drawn
139
lost
161
win % 42.1



Royle
played
118
won
47
drawn
36
lost
35
win % 40%
Click to expand...

image.webp
 
davek said:
Barry is as influential if not more so; Barkley has far more talent in his locker. That's just from this squad.

Arteta was a very good player, but let's not go overboard. He went to Arsenal and wasn't given a creative role - he played a much more of a recycling role. There's no way that would happen to Barkley if he made a move to a CL spot team. For us he was instrumental, elsewhere in a more talented outfit he was a bit part player.

But the issue here isn't his playing ability it's his coaching ability. If both Wenger and Guardiola badly wanted him that's high praise indeed.

He WILL be shortlisted when Koeman moves on.
Click to expand...

Dear me. People forget how good Arteta was (as well as Pienaar Cahill and Osman in their prime). Probably why those teams finished in league positions that are now seen as unobtainable. His cruciate injury destroyed him and it's actually a measure of the player he was that even after the injury stripped him of most of his strength and pace he was still good enough to play for Arsenal. Arteta pre-injury was fantastic.

I agree though that if he can make the jump from coach to manager he could be a future Everton manager.
 
Saint Domingo said:
Dear me. People forget how good Arteta was (as well as Pienaar Cahill and Osman in their prime). Probably why those teams finished in league positions that are now seen as unobtainable. His cruciate injury destroyed him and it's actually a measure of the player he was that even after the injury stripped him of most of his strength and pace he was still good enough to play for Arsenal. Arteta pre-injury was fantastic.

I agree though that if he can make the jump from coach to manager he could be a future Everton manager.
Click to expand...

I wouldn't say David's "forgot" how good Arteta was mate. Just think about who signed him.
 
Hasn't got a lot of traction on here, but for me one of the most interesting comments yesterday was 'Sissoko would have completed the perfect picture'.

Seems that Koeman was after him to fill several different positions (CM, AM, WM) in the midfield.

Way I see it, Koeman sees the squad as:

Goalkeepers (3)
- Stekelenburg
- Joel
- Hewelt

Defenders (9)
- Coleman
- Browning
- Holgate
- Williams
- Jagielka
- Pennington
- Funes Mori
- Baines
- Oviedo

Midfielders (8)
- Gueye
- McCarthy
- Barry
- Gibson
- Cleverley
- Davies
- Dowell
- Barkley

Forwards (7)
- Lukaku
- Kone
- Valencia
- Mirallas
- Lennon
- Deulofeu
- Bolasie

You can see from that how the squad is 'set-up' for the 4-3-3 system. He obviously felt that - possibly given the form of Stek and Holgate - the main area we could improve on deadline day was midfield and up front.

Maybe Valencia wasn't the first choice, but at least we got another option in who is better than what we had.

Sissoko, similarly, would have added pace, power and versatility - which in Koeman's mind is clearly what our midfield lacks. So I can definitely see that being an area targeted come January.
 
Saint Domingo said:
Dear me. People forget how good Arteta was (as well as Pienaar Cahill and Osman in their prime). Probably why those teams finished in league positions that are now seen as unobtainable. His cruciate injury destroyed him and it's actually a measure of the player he was that even after the injury stripped him of most of his strength and pace he was still good enough to play for Arsenal. Arteta pre-injury was fantastic.

I agree though that if he can make the jump from coach to manager he could be a future Everton manager.
Click to expand...

I loved Arteta - best midfielder in the league before his injury. 2007 to the early part of 09 he was sublime.
 

davek said:
Martinez
played won drawn lost 143 61 39 43 42.7
143
won
61
drawn
39
lost
43
win % 43%


Moyes
played
518
Won
218
drawn
139
lost
161
win % 42.1



Royle
played
118
won
47
drawn
36
lost
35
win % 40%
Click to expand...

Nice but I want that as league games not all games. Also while a goals scored per games ratio went up so did our goals conceded, a huge problem. We also drew far too may games.

Manager Stats show him as W60 L41 D43 Total 144 Win% 41.67

where as Moyes shows

W218 D139 L161 Total518 Win% 42.08

Either way both were not good enough.
 

Status
Not open for further replies.

Welcome

Join Grand Old Team to get involved in the Everton discussion. Signing up is quick, easy, and completely free.

Register

Shop

Back
Top