Rate the January 2026 Transfer Window

[when i score we riot]

Someone needs to go back through the last ten "rate the window" threads and give us the aggregate stats of how we've rated. This poll is clearly bonkers but at least IMDB gets sensible numbers out of everyone and their dog rating everything 0 or 10.

 

[Davideeyore]

Not really much to rate. 1 loan that is essential given the loss of Grealish. Reluctant to fix other areas. Summer will be critical

 

[Biff malibu]

Did we sign or sell anyone?

 

[MikeH72]

Just changed it from 0 to 10 based on the assumption McNeil is going.

Changed it to a 2.

 

[Fonzy]

TFG will be judged by the summer…all noises out of club is going to be summer!!

Well it really has to be…we need 4 Fullbacks, a CB (if Keane goes), a no 10, decide on Grealish/kid from chelsea. Plus 2 strikers…

 

[Daytripper]

TFG will be judged by the summer…all noises out of club is going to be summer!!

Well it really has to be…we need 4 Fullbacks, a CB (if Keane goes), a no 10, decide on Grealish/kid from chelsea. Plus 2 strikers…

They have been here a year , I don’t trust the “summer” narrative either, Thats been pushed before and we are already seeing it again on social media.

Don’t forget our own manager said last year it was difficult to attract a lot of the better players because of a lack of European football. He also said last month in an interview that potentially the best we could hope for over the next couple of years is around 8th or 9th, so we potentially face the same issues time and again.

 

[matty1878]

They have been here a year , I don’t trust the “summer” narrative either, Thats been pushed before and we are already seeing it again on social media.

Don’t forget our own manager said last year it was difficult to attract a lot of the better players because of a lack of European football. He also said last month in an interview that potentially the best we could hope for over the next couple of years is around 8th or 9th, so we potentially face the same issues time and again.

but if we’re only spending in the summer then it’s correct we have to wait

a year on more steady stable club

 

[Daytripper]

but if we’re only spending in the summer then it’s correct we have to wait

a year on more steady stable club

What if we run into the same issues we did last summer? No European football and the inability to attract much better players which is what we need to progress? I am only stating what the manager has said.

 

[marsh]

Awful

 

[evertony]

Positive in the fact that TFG don’t appear to trust Moyes with the money. It perhaps suggests that he will be replaced too in the Summer.
Either that or they are happy with the improvement over last season thus far.

 

[Bebeto]

Since the summer or even since the takeover at the end of last year, I have little to no expectations really other than make sure we remain a pl club. I am still convinced we dont have the right people at the top, or even if TFG has the ambition to really give this a proper go. Ultimately I am content of finishing the window with a stronger squad that we started with (minus the grealish injury).

 

[Howards tipple]

I didnt think we would buy anyone, so the fact we did is a bonus.

Losing Dwight McNeil (whilst we have really needed him in previous seasons, just hasn't done it this year) and getting 15 to 20 million is a major coup.

Better than I thought but it's probably a 3....zero nothing happens, 10 we smash it. Something happened but not a lot.

Edit.. Read that he hasn't gone for any cash... drop the rating to a 1. FFS

 

[SJB]

Losing Dwight McNeil (whilst we have really needed him in previous seasons, just hasn't done it this year) and getting 15 to 20 million is a major coup.

The Dwight McNeil deal fell through.

 

[Howards tipple]

The Dwight McNeil deal fell through.

Just edited the post, thanks though mate. Like finding out Father Christmas isn't real

 

[Swartzy]

2/10 for what i wanted

10/10 for what i expected