Rank our recent managers.

[Furey1878]

(most to least)

Ancelotti - made us dream
Moyes - stable but unambitious
Martinez - exciting but flawed
Silva - Martinez-lite
Dyche - dour and pragmatic, but horrible circumstances
Allardyce - just dour and pragmatic
Benitez - horrible from start to finish and a red
Lampard - completely and utterly out of his depth

I think it is easy to forget how utterly tragic we were under Lampard. I liked him as a person, but dear lord he was unfit to manage at this level.

What about Koeman, Zez?

 

[Jimishorts]

Yes most of our recent managers have been rank.

 

[Jamiednm]

1. Moyes (made us stable, competitive, played some great stuff, team spirit was brilliant, we were unfortunate not to win a trophy or two)
2. Martinez (first season)
3. Ancelotti
4. Dyche
5. Silva
6. Allardyce
7. Koeman
8. Benitez
9. Lampard

 

[bluelife]

Interesting take on Ancelotti - he had some equally horrendous results at home in his full season in charge. Strugglers like West Ham, Fulham, Burnley, Villa and Sheff Utd all got 3 points at Goodison in the second half of 20/21 season.

I reckon he half knew he was off to some skirt-lifting megaclub in the summer so effectively lost interest. Shame as we were definitely on for Europe if not top 4 that season.

 

[Ed_Winchester]

I reckon he half knew he was off to some skirt-lifting megaclub in the summer so effectively lost interest. Shame as we were definitely on for Europe if not top 4 that season.

He definitely lost interest, whether he knew Madrid were going to come calling or just being on the inside of Everton was enough to drive him nuts.

 

[matty1878]

He definitely lost interest, whether he knew Madrid were going to come calling or just being on the inside of Everton was enough to drive him nuts.

lol

 

[matty1878]

He definitely lost interest, whether he knew Madrid were going to come calling or just being on the inside of Everton was enough to drive him nuts.

i couldn’t believe it when we got him

shame covid hit and shame madrid come sniffin

 

[Rita_Poon]

Carlo
Moyes
Silva

There are no others. Dyche is under examination.

 

[Huyton Layne]

Probably 5/10 for everyone. Be arsed caring about any of them we've had since 95.

We're still in the Premier League but haven't won a bean since before Jack Harrison was born.

 

[Zezti]

What about Koeman, Zez?

Heck, forgot. Between Dyche and Allardyce.

 

[Cake]

He definitely lost interest, whether he knew Madrid were going to come calling or just being on the inside of Everton was enough to drive him nuts.

His mind was elsewhere after his home was burgled.

 

[Cork Evertonian]

1 David Moyes

2 Roberto Martinez First season was very good.

3 Carlo Ancelotti

4 Marco Silva That eight place finish under him hasn't been bettered since.

5 Sean Dyche

6 Sam Allardyce

7 Ronald Koeman

8 Frank Lampard

9 Fat Kopite Pig

 

[Look to the future]

Carlo, Moyes
Martinez
Silva

The rest were/are crap

 

[Kev The Rat]

1 Allardyce

2 Moyes

3 Martinez

4 Silva

5 Ancelotti

6 Lampard

7 Koeman

8 Dyche/Benitez

 

[Mr Happy]

Lampard the worst by far

Eh ?