Player ratings season so far...

[Hellerad]

I'd rate Gibson higher based solely on the fact that the squad immediately lost its shape and solidity the moment he was injured. It has been something we have lacked every game since and is the clearest weakness in the squad.

That assumes his form would have continued, but it has been clear to me that our midfield has been patchwork at best without him.

 

[Goat]

Fact is Moyes would kill Falcao if he was here.

 

[Southall]

Bit harsh on Neville IMO. Hes been playing centre mid most of season and were sat in 5th. Last two games dare i say we have missed him?

 

[DanEFC92]

Bit harsh on Neville IMO. Hes been playing centre mid most of season and were sat in 5th. Last two games dare i say we have missed him?

I'd of given him a 6 myself.

 

[RFUS]

Howard: -6.7 million
Coleman: 6
Jagielka: 7
Heitinga: Koff
Distin: 6.5
Baines: Too good for mere numbers

Osman: 7.5
Pienaar: 4
Mirallas: 7.5
Fellaini: 8.5

Jelavic: 6
Anichebe: 7

Be arsed with the rest.

 

[Elong]

Rate Jelavic a little higher, he's still been scoring a decent return of goals if you look at the entire season. And Howard I'd drop down a couple points, bloody hopeless this season. Otherwise not bad.

 

[ijjysmith]

Christ he even celebrates bossly.

 

[SheedyBracewellReidSteven]

Christ he even celebrates bossly.

Doubt the groundsman is his biggest fan ripping up the pitch like that.

 

[Bainaar]

Move Neville upto a 6. Drop Felli + Mirallas to 7. Jelavic 5. Wouldnt bother rating Hitz, Gibbo, Hibbo etc

 

[Bainaar]

The fickleness regarding Jelavic is astounding.

as was the hype after a few good games. People beginning to realise he isnt that good whatsoever

 

[ijjysmith]

as was the hype after a few good games. People beginning to realise he isnt that good whatsoever

Hi Changy. x

 

[ToffeeDan]

Howard 5
Hibbo 5 Coleman 5
Heitinga 5
Jags 7
Baines 8
Big Man 6.5
Neville 6

Ossie 7.5
Pienaar 5
Big Fella 9
Mirallas 9
Hitz 6
Nais 6
Gibbo 7
Oviedo 7
Gueye 4

Anichebe 8 or 4 (according to his mood)
Jeli 6