Player ratings season so far...

[ijjysmith]

Quite ballgreedy too, a few times squaring it to Jelavic would have been a way better option than when he chooses to go for personal glory.

Actually don't mind his greedyness.

A few more players could take note of that.

 

[ToffeeBlueNose]

Actually don't mind his greedyness.

A few more players could take note of that.

Got to agree wish more players would shoot on sight sometimes. don't know about ossie though not sure a long range shot would reach the goal

 

[ijjysmith]

Got to agree wish more players would shoot on sight sometimes. don't know about ossie though not sure a long range shot would reach the goal

What the hell is it with Osman and shooting?!

Is it his little legs?

 

[ToffeeBlueNose]

What the hell is it with Osman and shooting?!

Is it his little legs?

haha pigeon sticks aren't they

 

[toffeejack]

pretty much spot on OP (if the ratings are out of 10) - would be inclined to give distin a 6, but that's probably because i love him so, don't think he's been that bad, we just haven't defended well as a team, can't remember much goals that were 'his' fault. Could be a case to agree with ijjy on mirallas, but whenever he's been on the pitch, he's worth an 8. Think felli could be a 10, because let's be honest here, what more could he have done, been fricking fantastic

 

[The-Golden-Vision]

The fickleness regarding Jelavic is astounding.

 

[CahillsCornerFlag]

Heitinga is a 3 for me, Pienaar a 4. Baines gets a 9. The others I agree with.

 

[ah11984]

GK
Howard 4

Defenders
Jags 7
Distin 5
Heitinga 5
Hibbert 6
Coleman 6
Baines 9

Midfield
Gibson 7
Neville 5
Osman 7
Hitzleberger 6
Pienaar 5
Mirallas 7
Fellaini 9

Strikers
Jelavic 6
Vic 6
Naismith - 6

 

[meagher94]

Agree with most of it, except for Jelavic "hardly getting service". He's had quite a few chances that he should've slotted, his finishing and sometimes decision making has been poor apart from his 4 or 5 goals.

He's just in poor form. I love the guy and I can bet my life he'll be slotting regularly again pretty soon, but I'm not gonna sugar coat it and put it down to 'no service'.

 

[Chang Elephant]

Osman 7 - finally not being stuck out on the wings has helped him look an accomplished player. Turned up for a derby and got an England cap. His best season IMO.

Osman 5 - looks a tidy player, but can be completely anonymous at times, easily dispossessed, and has the shot of a five year old girl. One of the reasons teams are running through our midfield at will, and making the central defence look worse than it is.

 

[Lien]

The fickleness regarding Jelavic is astounding.

100% agree. The criticism of Jelavic on this forum is mind-blowing. He's had a few poor games. And now he's suddenly crap? 5 league goals from 12 games ain't too crap at all. He's not what I'd call a prolific striker as in will get 20+, but I'd be surprised if he didnt get 15. Completely exaggerated comments about him on here.

 

[ijjysmith]

Fact is Moyes would kill Falcao if he was here.

 

[SheedyBracewellReidSteven]

pretty much spot on OP (if the ratings are out of 10) - would be inclined to give distin a 6, but that's probably because i love him so, don't think he's been that bad, we just haven't defended well as a team, can't remember much goals that were 'his' fault. Could be a case to agree with ijjy on mirallas, but whenever he's been on the pitch, he's worth an 8. Think felli could be a 10, because let's be honest here, what more could he have done, been fricking fantastic

About the only gash thing Fellaini is guilty of was not scoring a relative sitter against WBA. He has been superb in all except a couple of games really.

 

[Blue 1]

The fickleness regarding Jelavic is astounding.

This.

 

[toffeeabroad]

I think Jelavic is just going through a bad patch. We will see him at his best very soon. Could easily have had a 6th goal had albino boy not messed up his pass the other day.

The ratings are spot on for me expect maybe for Mirallas. He looks great on the pitch but is a bit too lightweight/injury prone.