the only point I would accept there is Burrow is a better mover than I gave him credit for. I called him immobile and he clearly isnt so I stand corrected.
As for the rest, you have made stuff up there - I never said Mahomes was the most successful qb in history, I said he was the best. You are so totally focussed on rings and total wins and total yards that you ignore the fact that his overall skill set is like nothing we have ever seen before.
Yet again, ignoring everything that proves you wrong, and wriggling like crazy to try to suggest you said something different than you actually did.
I haven't made ANYTHING up there. Your posts are in this thread for all to see. The best thing is you can't edit them, so contradicting yourself now is a fool's errand.
I'm not ignoring his Mahomes' skill set. I'm countering your suggestion that his skillset makes him the best QB ever. One can praise the skillset (and rightly so) without descending into giddy hyperbole and claiming it amounts to more than it really does. How can someone be the best if their achievements are dwarfed by those of others? The skillset isn't even unique - you're acting like there's never been a QB who could run effectively before Mahomes got drafted.
Is Mahomes already a better runner than Brady and/or Montana? Yes, emphatically. At their best, Brady was a mediocre athlete (in NFL terms) and Montana was above average. Mahomes is miles better than that on a bad day!
Is Mahomes already a better passer than Brady and/or Montana? Nope. Although Montana is retired and Brady is in decline. Mahomes has time to improve, so that MIGHT change.
Is Mahomes already a better game manager than Brady and/or Montana? Nope. Same remarks as per passing.
Does Mahomes already have a postseason record to match Brady and/or Montana ? PAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHA not even close. BUT let's see what happens over the next ten years. If he wins three or four more rings then will legitimately have grounds to be regarded as better than Montana. But he'll need more than that to equal Brady.
So therefore there is no logical, rational way to label Mahomes as the best ever. It's simply too early in his career.
When you see pundits and analysts saying "Mahomes might be the best QB we've ever seen" they are pointing to his skillset and saying he has most of the tools necessary to overtake Brady and Montana OVER TIME. You find me a single respectable NFL coach, GM analyst or pundit who categorically states that Mahomes is ALREADY better than Brady or Montana - go ahead. I'll wait.
But you'll ignore all those points and refer instead to regular season passer rating, ignoring as you do so that Mahomes gets to pad his stats against the Raiders, the Chargers and the Broncos twice a season and waving away any losses as someone else's fault or sheer fluke.
