Patto played 1000 minutes- 2 assists.
Ashley played 2200 minutes- 0 assists.
Coleman played 664 minutes- 0 assists.
Defensively, all of them were very hit and miss (Coleman more so when he got extended runs). Young to me was by far the worst defender and made the most egregious errors that cost us games. Coleman just couldn’t really string together performances but he had some good moments. Patto just wasn’t favored and couldn’t get consistent gametime despite being the best offensive option by far. None of them were great defensively.
There was obviously tension between Patto and Dyche- maybe Patto is a hothead and got on his bad side. I have no idea. If all of them are inconsistent defensively, it makes no sense not to go with Patto. If that is the case, get that RB in. It is mandatory.