Charlie Sweet
Player Valuation: £35m
Needs a loan. Could then be a decent player.
- Status
Usual nobs this morning.
DuncanPatterson
Player Valuation: £5m
This whole thread is an embarrassment
Full of gaslighting old cranks with nothing better to do than try and tear down a young professional footballer's career
It's GrandOldTeam's shame
Hopefully no potential signings or their representatives ever come on these forums
Rugby Toffee
Player Valuation: £60m
I like him , no Gary Stevens , but you can see he has potential. Should start before both Coleman and Young IMO.
The Binman
Player Valuation: £15m
I'd rotate him and Coleman...
Charlie Sweet
Player Valuation: £35m
Ha ha can you not take calm civil debate and comment? I've said I think he's a decent lad and could have something going forward but he's obviously very weak defensively.
This isn't his fault. It's just crazy the circumstances on which we signed him.
In the season we got him from Rangers he'd made 6 (six) league appearances and 4 of them were as substitute coming on late.
Why on earth did Rafael Benitez sign him? £12M up front. Of the £4M extras given we were a relegation threatened team and clearly desperate to sign him (we'd been on to Steven Gerard several times) then it's reasonable to assume the majority of those add ons are linked to staying in the league given we were (and are) a million miles from any silverware. And a 5.5 year contract. Just insane.
As I've said if he was an Academy graduate he'd not get any not this attention. Its because we literally got a 10 point penalty for financial incompetence like this that frustrates people
Marius57
Player Valuation: £60m
Is it? We had finished 10th the previous season. The clubs planning will have forecast us to be finishing mid table or higher even if we had had a tricky start.
interesting how your choice of language has changed from last week when you were making out like we had spent potentially 19m on his transfer fee.
In a game where for the first time ever as the whole team was pathetic in our MOTM poll has not one vote, the trolls pick on one player - FGS grow up -
davek
Player Valuation: £150m
Joey, you cant teach a defensive mindset. You have it or you don't.
I remember Stones when he was here and I said at the time he was never a top class defender and that he looked a central midfielder like Carrick.
To me Patterson is a wide player. Play him there or nowhere...certainly nowhere near a defence.
The jury is in. Never mind he's 22 years old and 'needs to develop'. You cant plait sawdust.
But Stones now is a top class defender so not really sure why you dug your own grave there.
Charlie Sweet
Player Valuation: £35m
It is easy past £19m as a total investment yes.
Marius57
Player Valuation: £60m
Coleman at 22 couldnt play right back and needed to develop
Trolls , WUM's ,Multi's all pretty easy to spot Joey , first thing they do is hide their profile.
Whole team was way below what's required yesterday , they all look shattered to me.
Strongly doubt he'll be loaned our given out paper thin squad.
Marius57
Player Valuation: £60m
That’s not what you said.
So specifically £16m and then “another 2 or 3”. So 19m.
Then a 5 year contract at 70k a week. (Which is also a lie as he isn’t even on £40k a week).
You then said you would share your evidence of all this which you never did. As you seemed certain it was about us staying in the league which there’s no evidence of.
You are all over the place on this thread. Some may suggest it’s just wumming.
- Status
Welcome
Join Grand Old Team to get involved in the Everton discussion. Signing up is quick, easy, and completely free.
Shop
