Moyes or Benitez ???

[BNJ1878]

The problem with Moyes is that he may well get your team competing in the right half of the table...but that's it.

The man is a serial bottler.

I was almost in the 'anybody but Moyes' camp over the summer.

 

[tommye]

You generally look at credentials of a manager to determine likelihood of success.

That's why we don't appoint Phil from Skem FC

I'd have Phil from Skem FC over fatty.
NEA

 

[blue to the bone]

The problem with Moyes is that he may well get your team competing in the right half of the table...but that's it.

The man is a serial bottler.

I was almost in the 'anybody but Moyes' camp over the summer.

I set that camp up.

 

[Thomasc]

Wonder how our fan base would have reacted if we had appointed Ranieri?

 

[tommye]

Wonder how our fan base would have reacted if we had appointed Ranieri?

Can't be any worse than a kopite.

 

[Nymzee]

You generally look at credentials of a manager to determine likelihood of success.

That's why we don't appoint Phil from Skem FC

Thank Christ we didn't look at managerial credentials before hiring Howard Kendall then.

 

[MACCA75]

Moyes. Have never understood the issues people have about him coming back.
We needed someone who wasn’t going to burn money and he was absolutely the man. Still is.

 

[Thomasc]

Thank Christ we didn't look at managerial credentials before hiring Howard Kendall then.

Blackburn / Skem

bit of a difference like

 

[Rob17896]

Lot of discord surrounding the appointment of our current manager and you can’t ignore the decent job our former boss is doing at West Ham… out of interest then who would you prefer here now ?

Rafael...they are similar but Rafael has better experience and is a bit more of a pull for players. Rafael has started the season several steps behind Moyes. He has a lot more dross to contend with.

Moyes would have been controversial to appoint and possibly given just as hard a time by our fans. Agent Rafael or Traitor Moyes?

 

[Tubey]

It's threads like this that are making me less and less arsed about Everton and football in general.

Stupid.

 

[Nymzee]

Blackburn / Skem

bit of a difference like

So is referring to Moyes as a "random bloke from Skem" kinda manager.

Personally couldn't give a toss what a manger has won as long as they're the right fit for our club. Carlo won the lot and he was a crap Everton manager.

 

[MikeH72]

Moyes is the type of manager we need right now as a club.

 

[Kurt.]

It's threads like this that are making me less and less arsed about Everton and football in general.

Stupid.

Don’t read it then … simple

 

[allen]

BOTH

 

[allen]

Very reactive.

Wasn't long ago West Ham fans wanted Moyes out - the covid break saved him.

He got a bit of time but come the end of both Benitez and Moyes careers there will only be one answer on who was the more successful/better manager.

There's also only 3 points seperating the sides.

Benitez will say 8th means nothing.
Moyes will say 8th means manager of the season.

The biggest difference is how long each has had in their respective jobs. Moyes being there for a second time only means his feet are even further under the desk.

Judge Moyes now against Benitez in a year or two.