2018/19 Marco Silva - New Poll Added

Grade Marco Silva's 2018/19 Season

  • A

  • B

  • C

  • D

  • E

  • F


Results are only viewable after voting.
Status
Not open for further replies.
No, it really isn’t. That’s the point. It’s not that it doesn’t happen. Sometimes it does. But most of the time it takes much longer.

Consistency is basically the last thing that clicks.

This.

It takes more than 6 months to have your team playing in 100% your style. And in the PL modern era, a lot more £££ than he has spent.
 
I meant it tongue in cheek, because obviously relegation or even finishing close to it won’t happen (I know, famous last words) but at the end of the day, we’re 21 games into a season and the feeling is just a tad meh.

By the way, I’m not advocating sacking Silva like some, I’ve defended him on here now a fair few times. For me he gets this window (now looking unlikely we’ll bring anyone in) and the Summer transfer window, then next season Is when lads can rightly scrutinise him to the hilt.

Will be interesting to know what is everyone expectation next season under Silva?
 
Bielsa hasn't "proved this wrong" - he is doing what he usually does, getting players to buy in to his methods. When he will have problems is when they decide they've had enough of his antics, or when the board doesnt back him in whatever he thinks is right and he ragequits.

He is a great visionary, but his disciples probably learn what not to do from him as much as they adopt his methods - thats why although they ape his tactics, Guardiola / Simeone / Poch etc do not get sacked within a couple of years and why they've (well, except Poch) actually win things. As a manager I'd rate Moore ahead of him, what he has done at West Brom has been exceptional (and if he had been appointed instead of Pardew they would not have gone down).
Darron Moore is better manager than Marcelo Bielsa? Based on what? 40 games in charge of West Brom who’s squad is easily one of the strongest in the Championship? :Blink:
 
Some stats from sky on Everton - depressing!

Pas the whisky Dave.

From chance creation to errors at the back, we pick out the stats which explain Everton's slide in form...
Five wins from seven games ahead of December had Everton fans enjoying Marco Silva's early progress at the club. New signings were impressing in an all-action, attacking style. One win in eight since then has reduced that optimism and left the new manager with increasing problems to solve.

Everton's previous two games highlight their recent issues. A set-piece at Brighton and an individual error against Leicester cost them both matches, and each has become a recurring characteristic of this side, particularly during this lapse of form.
Since the start of December, Opta have Everton recording six errors leading to shots in those eight games, having made just four in their opening 13. Four of those have then led to goals - a Premier League high - contributing to the alarming fact that almost half of the shots Everton have faced in this frustrating spell have been scored.
Everton in the Premier League this season
Pre December (PL rank) Stats per game Since December (PL rank) 1.2 (5th)Goals conceded2 (19th)1.16 (6th)Expected Goals Against (xGA)1.71 (17th)0.3 (4th)Errors leading to shots0.8 (17th)71% (8th)Save percentage56% (19th)

Defending set-pieces has been a constant weakness under Silva. Three of the last four goals conceded came this way, and Everton have already let in more than in the whole of last season. The fact this was one of the few areas the club performed well at during 2017/18 reflects poorly on Silva, whose Watford side had similar troubles.
A noticeable recent stylistic change has been the ease in which opponents have won the ball back in dangerous areas, which was not the case earlier in the season. Everton had surrendered the fewest high turnovers in the Premier League by early December. Over the last seven games, though, they've suddenly conceded the second most of any side, making them far more vulnerable.
Fewest high turnovers against
Up to Dec 3 Total Since Dec 3 Total 1. Everton301. Burnley142. Huddersfield332. Man City183. Man City403. Liverpool23 ,19. Brighton7919. Everton3920. Fulham8320. Bournemouth41

In attack, Silva's side has also struggled to open up defences on a regular basis, which has become far more evident during this recent run. They failed to create a single big chance, by Opta's definitions, in either of their last two games.

Creativity, specifically from open play, has been a regular issue for Everton over a number of seasons. In the last three, Ross Barkley remains the club's most creative player, despite not playing a single game in two of those three seasons.
Most chances created in open play - last three PL seasons for Everton
Player Total Games played Ross Barkley5636Leighton Baines5458Idrissa Gueye4984Romelu Lukaku4737Gylfi Sigurdsson3748
This is perhaps Everton's biggest current flaw. Lucas Digne has created the most chances this season, but many of those have come from crosses, which has become a primary feature of Silva's approach. In fact, no side has sent in more than Everton this season, which is also part of the problem.

Most crosses in PL this season
Team Total Scored from Avg per goal Everton482769Huddersfield4742237Leicester4384110PL Average371570
This focus has led to an element of predictability around Everton's attack, which opponents now seem prepared for. Silva's side scored five goals from crosses in their first nine games this season, but have done so just twice in the following 12, despite the fact they now resort to crossing even more.
Everton's attackers have been short on service

Everton in the Premier League this season
Pre Merseyside derby (PL rank) Stats per game Since Merseyside derby (PL rank) 21.7 (1st)Crosses25.4 (1st)2.3 (8th)Big chances1.6 (13th)5.6 (8th)Shots on target3.6 (17th)
Silva is a young manager at a club in need of a spell of stability. His starting XI is one of the youngest in the Premier League and he will need more transfer windows to construct a squad suited to his style. At the same time, he needs to show he can adapt his own methods and learn from previous mistakes. Everton continuing to fail in similar ways to his previous clubs will severely hurt his long-term prospects.
His side now face a favourable run of five fixtures against sides no higher than eighth in the table. This must be used to find a more balanced, consistent approach, while fixing some of these current faults.
http://www.skysports.com/football/teams/everton/stats
https://www.skysports.com/football/...senals-creative-burden-in-mesut-ozils-absence



https://www.skysports.com/football/...source=spotim&utm_medium=spotim_recirculation
https://www.skysports.com/watch/vid...604750/silva-distances-everton-from-batshuayi
https://www.skysports.com/watch/vid...on/11603082/super-sunday8217s-essential-stats
https://www.skysports.com/watch/vid...n/11600059/silva-we-need-to-work-on-mentality
https://www.skysports.com/watch/vid...n/11602497/everton-ready-to-back-brands-silva
https://www.skysports.com/watch/video/sports/football/teams/everton/11599049/silva-i-wont-panic-buy
 

Lose this one at home to a Mickey Mouse club like Bournemouth and he’s up the creek without a paddle.

Especially with moshiri firing one across his bow midweek and public ally.
 
Lose this one at home to a Mickey Mouse club like Bournemouth and he’s up the creek without a paddle.

Especially with moshiri firing one across his bow midweek and public ally.
So you'd keep sacking managers every six months?And never building anything? I have reservations about Silva but if we keep doing that, we will only spiral further.
 
I think we should keep hold of him until a suitable manager becomes available, he is not the man for us. I do believe that he is getting
progressively worse, his English is worse than when he first came to us, when he is questioned by a TV interviewer he looks like a
frightened child and doesn't give a sensible answer,for Christs sake can't anyone else see this.
 


Status
Not open for further replies.
Top