Very good question.
No, at £15 million Illy is the better signing.
In fact at whatever we paid for Garner he's a better signing.
2 superb deals by Kopite Kev I believe.
We are a burden to you mate.
You always sound like you drew the short straw, and we are a weight that you can't remove from your shoulders..
You are loyal to the clubs name, you are just to desperate pining for the Ingredients of the clubs you missed out on when you plucked that straw.
You live too many moves ahead of the game.
Viennablue
Player Valuation: £1m
Of course what you/we all find enjoyable in football is subjective.
However, I’d point out that he does more than recycle possession.
He has 6 goals and 5 assists this season. According to Transfermarkt.
N‘Diaye, a player we all also like watching has 6 goals and 3 assists.
Also it should be noted that sometimes recycling possession is a good thing to do if there isn’t a good opportunity to create something. Both KDH and N’Diaye are very good at this.
Enjoy what we have and hope we build on it in summer!
Kevsleftpeg
Player Valuation: £35m
That's a completely bizarre way of assessing the worth of a footballer or his usefulness to us a team. KDH is one of our best players along with Pickford, Jarrod, Garner and Ndiaye. I would never tune in to watch R7 or Haaland because I don't find them particularly likeable or interesting to watch but I don't question their effectiveness. Seems to me like you have made a terrible call and you are just unwilling to admit how badly wrong you were.
We don’t need a right back we have Coleman
Kevsleftpeg
Player Valuation: £35m
It just highlights that Big Oil doesn't actually understand football. He can't appreciate the nuances and intangibles that KDH brings to the team.
I'm surprised that you've only just realised this.
KDH is a cracking signing, but we got Illy and Garner together for not much difference in value.
Evermaarton
Player Valuation: £750k
Illy, KDH and Garner are all excellent signings. Let's just hope this is the standard for new players from now on!
There are some occasional messages linking KDH with a summertransfer to another club. The proposed transfer sum is always somewhere around £ 28 mil. I do understand that there are clubs interested in him but thinking he will make a move (highly unlikely) for only 28 mil is just stupid.
There are some occasional messages linking KDH with a summertransfer to another club. The proposed transfer sum is always somewhere around £ 28 mil. I do understand that there are clubs interested in him but thinking he will make a move (highly unlikely) for only 28 mil is just stupid.
Lob
Player Valuation: £60m
Both really good signings tbf. KDH just edges it for me though because of his Duncan Ferguson style passion for Everton and not having to have 4 weeks in Africa every year which actually ends being 8 weeks because you lose another 4 trying to build up the form again.
Both the best signings in years though.
Ignore these messages for your own sanity mate.
KDH doesn't walk in and walk out, Not a bloody chance..
I could have SWORN he was only like 24. Did not realize he was 27.
TheBigIguana
Player Valuation: £100m
I have him on multiple sites at 6 goals 3 assists, the same as Iliman.
It’s going to rile people up, but I still don’t see it as particularly impressive for the role he has. He’s essentially a second striker in attack. He also takes set pieces a lot. The production could be greater.
But beyond that I don’t think the goal return is repeatable. It’s a purple patch. He doesn’t shoot enough to keep scoring like this. And when you throw that on top of his passing game, which is mostly conservative and safe, I just don’t enjoy it or believe in it still.
He’s awesome at making that underlapping run in the inside left channel though. If it were possible to build an entire attack out of one run he’d be world class.
TheBigIguana
Player Valuation: £100m
His role is to do more than be useful, and I agree he’s useful, but I would like more in that role. I expect it tbh.
