John Stones

[formerly manx toffee]

Is he better than what we have. I think he probably is

 

[Lelouch]

Not for me.

 

[Goat]

Struggling for form and fitness at City.

Its a definite no from me.

If he was healthy and had some hunger, yes, but hes not and he isnt.

 

[Bigjoe]

Better than Keane so a big fat yes from me.

 

[KaiserEFC]

Not for me. Think he’s a crock, vastly overrated and personally I would like a lefty at the back.

 

[Encoder]

Nah. I didn't like him that much the first time around.

You could probably get better for less.

Also I don't get the obsession with bringing players back. You don't even get a new player lift from it.

Pienaar's return was so great it somehow granted the Stracq the ability to score against Chelsea. If thats not a lift I don't know what is.

 

[blueconverse]

Got our own stones now.

 

[Blue Piper]

Got our own stones now.

I have a pain in me stones

 

[CahillsCornerFlag]

If he could recapture the early days where he flew into aerial challenges with his bandage on his head like a young Terry Butcher whilst adding a bit of class on the ball then yes. Otherwise it’s a huge no.

 

[Archie Knox]

I'd pay 15m and 60k a week. That means he wouldn't be joining us.

 

[DuncanDisorderly88]

Yeah let's waste more money

A league two player was ripping into him a week ago

 

[Efcjake]

Young, English and better than what we have.

Fairly easy question.

 

[duncs pigeon]

Im a fan of John Stones but dont think it would be the right idea to bring him back. Interesting comments by Guadiloa last week abt him. He said it was up to him if he wanted to succeed and become a top player. Doesnt seem to have the mental strength to overcome his injuries, hope he can because he is a very good footballer.

 

[Joey66]

Now crocked never go back.....

 

[Stephen Gibson]

No. He's better than Keane for sure but it's not the route to take. Stones makes the odd mistake which i can accept but our fans will destroy him eventually & his head doesn't take much to fold from a football perspective.
I want new faces who haven't had the chance to be ruined by us yet.