IN HIS PRIME WHICH PLAYER?

[tim cahill]

Mark Hughes wasn't bad in his prime either.

 

[JimEFC]

He wasn't really past his best when we had him, but yeah it would've been nice.

Yeah I know, hence left-field. I also don't think he's that much better 10 years on. But it would have been nice is right.

 

[canuckblue]

Phil Neville.

 

[toffee matt]

Samuel eto'o or David Ginola

 

[TippEverton]

Having Sammy in his prime would have been an absolute joy.

 

[Reidy's Bottle Of Grecian]

Paul Power.

Oh Hold on... We Did get his best season ever, won the league and he was player of the year.

Unlucky City.

 

[JimEFC]

Would have liked more Lineker too - but he doesn't fit here because technically he was in his prime that season.

 

[Neiler]

Beardsley but even then he was awesome!

 

[JimEFC]

Having Sammy in his prime would have been an absolute joy.

Yeah! Imagine him up front with Marcus Bent though.... lol


He was too busy matching Man United's amount of European Cup wins...on his own.

 

[Howards tipple]

Eto'o is the best shout. I watch him now and still see flashes of brilliance.

 

[JimEFC]

Eto'o is the best shout. I watch him now and still see flashes of brilliance.

Every time the ball goes to him I'm halfway out of my seat. He's magic.

 

[L4Everton]

In your time watching Everton which player that played for the club who was past his best would you liked to have seen at Everton in his prime? Apart from present day which would be Eto'o, I would have to say Colin Todd. What's your thoughts?

Sadly Duncan Ferguson's prime lasted all too short a while. Had he looked after himself and avoided the injuries as best he could, he'd have got near double the goals he finished with.
Had Kanchelskis not been puppeted around by Rusian third party triads he'd have either stayed at Old Trafford or had even more of an impact with us.
Materazzi lifted the Word Cup as captain of his country, only Patrick Vieira has done the same and been a PL player.

Joe Parkinson could have been tough guy of the universe, but getting that close meant something had to give - his ACL - today it isn't a career killer, but he took the frightners to Keane. Sport is full of sucj near misses.

If Best hadn't been addled by drink, if Garcoigne had been slapped enough to grow up past an eleven year old, if if if...

 

[teppic]

You all lose. It is clearly Barry Horne.

 

[bluesb1970]

Sadly Duncan Ferguson's prime lasted all too short a while. Had he looked after himself and avoided the injuries as best he could, he'd have got near double the goals he finished with.
Had Kanchelskis not been puppeted around by Rusian third party triads he'd have either stayed at Old Trafford or had even more of an impact with us.
Materazzi lifted the Word Cup as captain of his country, only Patrick Vieira has done the same and been a PL player.

Joe Parkinson could have been tough guy of the universe, but getting that close meant something had to give - his ACL - today it isn't a career killer, but he took the frightners to Keane. Sport is full of sucj near misses.

If Best hadn't been addled by drink, if Garcoigne had been slapped enough to grow up past an eleven year old, if if if...

Wasn't his ACL, he had no cartlidge between his bones so they rubbed together!!

Anyway, Ian Wilson!

 

[ToffeeDan]

Kenny Sansom..

Saha to an extent - by the end he wasn't worth his place in the team