2018/19 Idrissa Gueye

Status
Not open for further replies.
Is that what you said when Schneiderlin "earned a move to MU"?

Schneiderlin was a very good player at one point, even when he came to us from Utd he was arguably our best player.

The fact is that Gueye is our best DM by a long shot, his “weaknesses” that fans moan over are coming to light due to him having to do the job of the player next to him. We will be a weaker side without him in it, unless we bring a decent replacement in.
 

Good player, not a great player. I recall his outstanding debut v Spurs (I think) on the opening day of the season - he was literally everywhere & said to the lad who sits next to me, we’ve got a good ‘un here.

I would expect Brands to have a much younger version already lined up.

Good luck IGG, nothing is forever at Everton & PSG is a dream move.
 
ive never really rated him, his stats are deceptive. he gives it away with poor passing that often then wins it back it makes it look like hes winning daft amount of tackles but i think a fair chunk of the time hes covering his own mistakes
 

I think the people wanting to keep him fall into the following brackets;

A -- Wouldnt sell in Jan but dont seem to grasp that his value will decrease significantly in summer

B -- Are too young to remember when we were successful and dont believe we should aspire to that level

C -- Remember Lukaku being sold and not adequately replaced

D -- Expect some miracle to happen where we win games despite having players who arent good enough or unsuited to how the manager and DOF wants us to play...not willing to give the manager time or just dont want to understand the poop were left in thanks to 4 past managers.

E -- Arent watching the games and reliant on highlights and stats


Everyone is entitled to their opinion.

My opinion is that we have Brands and Silva who have brought in quality players in the summer and id sell every non-brands/silva signing today and give them all the money and more to rebuild.

You have to trust the process or else why bother?


Oh, £30mil for Gana is highway robbery.
How about...

F. We have no adequate replacement and already needed another CM/DM in addition to Gana.

If we can bring in two more central players this window, fine. Let him go.
 
As much as he has his limitations, there are at least 10 others I'd rather shift before him. Though as we all know, you can only sell someone if there is interest.
 

Status
Not open for further replies.
Top