Everton Premier League era player nominees

[Cameron Manning]

Under.... wasn't this the first poll?

Sorry I wasn’t sure which way the poll was working although I’ve got to admit Carsley did nothing for me.

 

[W84 Dum Freeze]

Underrated: Thomasz Radzinski

Overrated: Zinadine Kilbane

( played better without him with 10 men when he was sent off once ! )

 

[Yush193]

Landon Donovan, didnt play long for us but fun to watch for the time he was here. But overall goes to either Jagielka or maybe Howard

 

[datblygu]

Underrated: Distin
Overrated: Iwobi (by Lampard)

 

[JobForTheMoyes]

James McFadden. Quite underrated considering how much skill he had.

 

[LABlue2]

Maybe Pienaar for overrated. Great player but gets a lot of “best premier league XI” shouts and think his lack of end product was one reason we couldn’t scrape into the CL spots. Also (mutually) benefitted from a world class LB in Baines to play with

 

[KaiserEFC]

Leon Osman for greatest player in the PL era

David Nugent for wasted potential

Kenwyne Jones for what could’ve been

 

[DOMNOLAN]

The people have spoken. We are now moving on to the next nomimee: most overrated.

Most underrated: Steven Naismith
Most overrated:??

siggurdson

 

[kiss the crest]

Rondon?

Or is this the wrong thread

 

[Lobworm]

Soz like. I am not buying into the 'Premier League era' malarkey. Footy was invented before then, and has largely got worse since the PLs inception.

Yours

A. M. Iseryarse

 

[Raino85]

Most Overrated PL Era: Dave Watson, legs had gone

 

[Saint Domingo]

Overrated: Keane. Has taken 7 years of sticking it into his own net almost every week before people have eventually turned on him.

 

[Cels]

​

The most underrated player - Leon Osman
The most overrated player - Duncan Ferguson

​

 

[Blue Smoke]

Overrated - Big Dunc

 

[Arteta2391]

Okay let's move on to the next, best Everton premier league era player nomination

Underrated: Naismith
Overrated: Ferguson
Best:??


my nomination for best Everton PL era: Mikel Arteta