Everton’s worst ever signing

[TheBigIguana]

The answer is still Bolasie but shoutout to Martinez for bringing us a terrible goalie, defender, midfielder, and striker all from the same relegated team in one summer.

Actually I liked Robles.

Robles is probably better than the current version of Pickford.

I mean it's crazy how everyone turned on Robles after a few games with mistakes, and rightly imo, consistency in goal is really the key, but we're still hoping that Pickford can turn it around.

 

[tom_b1807]

Bolasie:
£26 million
6 G/A
£4.3 million per G/A

Siggy:
£45 million
51 G/A
£0.88 million per G/A

Yes Siggy hasn't been great and was a tremendous waste of money but let's not pretend he's been Bolasie levels of useless

 

[Carloblues]

Bolasie:
£26 million
6 G/A
£4.3 million per G/A

Siggy:
£45 million
51 G/A
£0.88 million per G/A

Yes Siggy hasn't been great and was a tremendous waste of money but let's not pretend he's been Bolasie levels of useless

I really dislike siggy but bolasie was a whole new level of bad. He is without doubt the worst for me

 

[The_La]

Robles is probably better than the current version of Pickford.

I mean it's crazy how everyone turned on Robles after a few games with mistakes, and rightly imo, consistency in goal is really the key, but we're still hoping that Pickford can turn it around.

Robles was ok but I'll never shake the memory of him waving 3 goals in at Anfield without even diving

 

[JMT]

Bolasie had a little spell with Lukaku where things were clicking, I'd have to say Klassen or Gomes if we're being honest, Gomes has put in good performances but 1 goal and 5 assists in 70 appearances is pretty shocking for my boy Andre.
Klassen was just a disaster, Not fit for the league at all.

 

[SteStocksDJ]

A lot of the players listed are fairly recent. I’ve gone for Sandro.
Klaasen is second but only because we somehow managed to sell him.

in terms of worst signing in our history.
Alcaraz
Neill
Nyarko
Kroldrup
Gascoigne
Ginola
Mark Hughes

 

[Gilbert..]

Bizarre player listings. Is it near the 1st April? Where's the Marc Hottigers, Stefan Rehn, Claus Tomsens?
* Oh yeah Sandro

Sandro has to be a major contender. I read players who ok were not great. Like linderoth and hottiger.
But sandro. I mean he did fck all. And i mean fck all here.

 

[rochdaleblue]

If it is value for money. Bolasie and Gomes with their respective returns (goals and assists) have to be up there with our worst. Doesn’t even take into account the wages payed to them both over the course of their contract.

 

[zzr45]

A lot of the players listed are fairly recent. I’ve gone for Sandro.
Klaasen is second but only because we somehow managed to sell him.

in terms of worst signing in our history.
Alcaraz
Neill
Nyarko
Kroldrup
Gascoigne
Ginola
Mark Hughes

Neill? Considering we signed him on a free as cover, he did that job absolutely fine and we then sold him on for a profit, that’s an absolutely mad shout.

 

[Thacko]

Kroldrup couldn’t head a football. Literally his job and he couldn’t do it.

 

[hktoffee]

Of that list, it can only be between 2.

Klassen or Bolasie

Klassen literally did nothing. No goals or assists, so he just about edges it. But its close.

Minus £12m or £25m. We lost a lot more money on paper in Bolasie.

 

[hktoffee]

Bolasie:
£26 million
6 G/A
£4.3 million per G/A

Siggy:
£45 million
51 G/A
£0.88 million per G/A

Yes Siggy hasn't been great and was a tremendous waste of money but let's not pretend he's been Bolasie levels of useless

Yup he is fine. Yes we overpaid a bit but he is alright overall.

 

[ToffeeTim]

Minus £12m or £25m. We lost a lot more money on paper in Bolasie.

Value for money I'd say its Bolasie. For actual output based on what we originally paid, it's Klassen

Thankfully the squad will be rid of a lot more poor players come June

 

[Thomasc]

So what? Cuco Martina scored a screamer for Southampton, are you saying only good players can score great goals?

Erm no not at all.
Why are you trying to completely negate the good things that he has done by trivialising them?

 

[Thomasc]

it is weird Thomas. It’s like some fans don’t understand the concept of other fans getting sick to the back teeth of certain players. It’s very strange, it’s like they watch football in a bubble and don’t know that there’s a long history of fans being done with players to the point of no return.

you’ve done well to highlight it, even if you’ve gone a bit far in calling them scruffs

Just a cheeky bit of banter mate, don’t be offended.