Transfer Rumour Christian Benteke

Status
Not open for further replies.

I reckon Benteke would be a great signing and at a great age.

Arguably the best Premier League striker in the air and knows how to score. Having a proper target man would really help players like Rooney, Sandro and Klassen score goals and it'd help against the big teams as we'll be able to retain posession better, which will help take a lot of pressure off our defence.

I think a lot of you are underestimating how much Palace will want for him though. I think they'll expect at least 50m to consider selling him, imo.
 
I reckon Benteke would be a great signing and at a great age.

Arguably the best Premier League striker in the air and knows how to score. Having a proper target man would really help players like Rooney, Sandro and Klassen score goals and it'd help against the big teams as we'll be able to retain posession better, which will help take a lot of pressure off our defence.

I think a lot of you are underestimating how much Palace will want for him though. I think they'll expect at least 50m to consider selling him, imo.
Agreed given what Lukaku went for and what Sig is being quoted at. Even if Lukaku is twice the player that Benteke is (and I'm not sure he is even that) then 50m is the ballpark figure.
 
Price has to be right though. He's limited and the price should reflect that.

£30M top whack or we've been ripped off for the 4th time in weeks.
 

In a vacuum Benteke would be a fine addition. I think he could do the job Koeman will want done and pitch in 15 goals or so.

The problem is, much as with Gylfi, he will simply cost too much for the return. You think Palace will want less than 50? I don't.

He, nor Gylfi, are worth 50. Time for Walshy to roll up his sleeves and head to the continent. For the same 100m that gets you Gylfi and Benteke he could probably come back with Jose/Bakambu, Forsberg and a cb like Lemos - probably with enough left over to pick up a LB like Robinson. Be out less on wages too....
 

They're completely different types of player

Benteke is a target man, aerially dominant, plays with his back to goal a lot etc - in his early days at Villa he had a bit of pace too, but not so much now

Lukaku is bang average in the air, poor with his back to goal but is fast and powerful and wants the ball in behind

They're compared because they're tall, muscular, black, Belgian strikers. But their styles are completely different

I'm not saying I definitely want him by the way, but the comparison is just daft
Just saying, people are claiming he is Lukaku's replacement. He's nothing like Lukaku and therefore can't be his replacement. It's not like for like. The style is different and Koeman would have to change tactics to play into Benteke strengths. Would need a new left back who can bomb forward and another winger.
 
my question is, based on the new additions, what do you see as being koeman's new attacking strategy going forward, and what kind of striker would that strategy fit
 
His scoring record is excellent though, 15 goals in a Palace team that only came to life in the last quarter of the season. He got 9 in 15 games for the RS and his record at Villa was sublime.

What he could do in a team featuring Rooney Siggy and overlapping full backs wets the appetite.
 

Status
Not open for further replies.

Welcome

Join Grand Old Team to get involved in the Everton discussion. Signing up is quick, easy, and completely free.

Shop

Back
Top