TheBigIguana
Player Valuation: £90m
Koeman is a good one.
- Status
LeeCarsley
Player Valuation: £8m
Dis Carlo guy stinks! Bring back Fat Sam and his trusty assistant Lee!
How quickly into his spell in charge did you start to have misgivings about him?
Just trying to build context for where you are with Ancelotti.
TheBigIguana
Player Valuation: £90m
There was no time with Koeman. Rom kept him competent for a year and it was done within like 4 months of the next. So I don't know tbh, I'm obviously no there with Carlo.
The word regularly is key I think. Failing to win home games against Leeds, Fulham, palace, Newcastle, Burnley and West Ham is fine when each game is taken in isolation. When you don’t beat any of them it’s a problem, and pretty clearly so. I honestly find it strange that this needs explaining.
Yeah, sounds similar to my memory of time under Koeman too.
I didn't mean to make it sound like you were, by the way. I was just keen to get your perspective.
TheBigIguana
Player Valuation: £90m
My feeling on Carlo is in a word concerned. The pedigree is not something many managers can top, but the things that I personally look for in a side that say they're good or at least improving have been largely absent from our team. And I'm starting to see a concerning trend where we look competent when James plays and are just grinding out games whenever he isn't on the pitch.
I'm not giving up because I do think the squad has holes and I do think some of the form we've had isn't a total accident either. But I just think ultimately we need to take an ever so slightly longer term view in order to build to a place where we are competitive instead of trying to just do it.
gonetomorrow
Player Valuation: £70m
I hope Carlo can admit to errors of judgement. He should not have taken off Coleman last night.
Why?
Coleman was ran into the ground playing for some backwater National team.
And everybody tells me Godfrey is a world class player.
The way he let Batman drift in was League Two stuff.
APN_EFC
Player Valuation: £25m
Ancelotti's impact I hope will be far greater than just his league position:
- A win at Anfield
- Positive mentality and a more brave, grown-up attitude.
- A 'bigger person' mentality - he doesn't make excuses, despite the absence of at least one out of Allan, Doucoure, James at all times, as well as DCL, Mina, Digne, Coleman, Pickford on several occassions - all first choice.
- Calm manner well in control
- Improved a few players - DCL, Keane, Holgate, Davies for starters
- Seems to really want to improve, make Everton better, and stay for more than his current contract.
- If he stays for at least 3 years, we will get another few Allan calibre players and maybe one more in the elite category if we get into Europe.
He has brought a change in attitude, profile and seriousness to Everton, and if we take advantage of this we'll see a much bigger improvement. I know everyone has the same excuse, but this season has for some reasons been a write off, and for us in transition it's hard. i know the Away form might flip again, but just imagine if we were at Goodison, some of those draws and losses would have been turned around by the crowd - at least 4-5 points for sure!
- A win at Anfield
- Positive mentality and a more brave, grown-up attitude.
- A 'bigger person' mentality - he doesn't make excuses, despite the absence of at least one out of Allan, Doucoure, James at all times, as well as DCL, Mina, Digne, Coleman, Pickford on several occassions - all first choice.
- Calm manner well in control
- Improved a few players - DCL, Keane, Holgate, Davies for starters
- Seems to really want to improve, make Everton better, and stay for more than his current contract.
- If he stays for at least 3 years, we will get another few Allan calibre players and maybe one more in the elite category if we get into Europe.
He has brought a change in attitude, profile and seriousness to Everton, and if we take advantage of this we'll see a much bigger improvement. I know everyone has the same excuse, but this season has for some reasons been a write off, and for us in transition it's hard. i know the Away form might flip again, but just imagine if we were at Goodison, some of those draws and losses would have been turned around by the crowd - at least 4-5 points for sure!
billyblue80
Player Valuation: £70m
He isn't a wing back
Yeah expecting a defender to be able to defend is asking a lot.
billyblue80
Player Valuation: £70m
They have more balance and team work we have a few good individuals and imbalance. Anyway it's hard to judge it is a weird season without fans I do have criticism of Carlo but I refuse to believe our home record is the same with fans in the ground.
billyblue80
Player Valuation: £70m
He lost his man so did Keane. It happens, happens more when you are in a unfamiliar position.
- Status
