Best Player Moyes has ever signed?

[Jimboefc97]

Fellaini or Jelavic

 

[mpatton]

Cahill should never be mentioned in threads like these, he was just a PR machine intended to placate our fans during a woeful period without helping the team, not the kind of player I want at EFC.

wtf? I know we all have different views, but we all have one common goal and thats for our great club to be the best it can be, I had to read this twice to believe what i was reading. I never normally get involved with debates but whilst i wouldn't put Tim Cahill as Moyes best signing, he is certainly up there. I believe strongly that Tim contributed a great deal to the club and that he was a fantastic buy. A PR machine? Never. Sorry but this has rattled me almost as much as the officials at the Newcastle game.

One thing this thread has made me even more aware is on balance Moyes gets it more right than wrong in the transfer market.

Arteta for the same reason Paulefc states. He contributed, we bought him young and was great value and we sold him for £10m making a substantial profit. Martyn - for sure but I'm going to stick my neck out for Fellaini as I think he really is our stand out player and the majority of managers in the premier league would have him if they could. At £15m he wasn't cheap but when we sell him for £30m - £35m then he will officially be Moyes best signing in my eyes.

 

[grandjoeblue]

Baines or Fellaini for me. Best two players I have seen play for us I think, I am only 20 though.

 

[Summerskin]

Hahaha, I got three of you with that Cahill comment.

You so easy!

 

[tasslehoff]

Did anyone say Castillo?

Those thighs..

 

[Foot Long Hot Dog]

Hahaha, I got three of you with that Cahill comment.

You so easy!

Hilarious, what a wag you are.

 

[TheFinnFan]

it is too early to say that Gibson is his best signing ever imo but in shorter period he is number one, easily.
the fact that ferguson let him go for that price is just too amazing. and the impact to our game. just jizz.
hopefully he is slotting with blues in derby

 

[DualityNSNO]

Bilyaletdinov, Jo, van der Meyde.

A Holy Trinity.

 

[Evertonized]

I would say Tim Howard, Leighton Baines & if he keeps it up, Jelavic

 

[Goat]

Mikel Arteta.

 

[DanEFC92]

The spanish magician.

 

[tim cahill]

Based on what we've seen so far Jelavic has got to be up there!

 

[CahillsCornerFlag]

Arteta. Followed by Baines then Cahill.

 

[bobafro]

Arteta + Baines + Jagielka + Jelavic + Mirallas + Pienaar + Gibson + Naismith + Martyn + Howard + Cahill + Lescott = around the same money as andy caroll

rofl

 

[bobafro]

as an aside... Lescott is worth a mention as well.. he was spectacular down the left before baines broke in and then the partnership with jags was great. we also earned a mint off him.