Bad ref decisions - for and against - season 2025/26

[pfim]

To be fair, I thought we got lucky when Garner blatantly pushed that fella over in the box.

Didn’t see anything against us that was questionable. Think this situation looked worse than it was, it turned out to only be a one handed push and he missed him with the right hand. In no world should a man of that size fall to the floor being pushed with one hand by Jimmy Garner

 

[Bedfordblue]

I thought VAR would have gave it.

I think after the WWE stuff last week, they were probably under orders to not give a pen unless unavoidable to prevent more scrutiny on their ridiculous flip flopping of rule application.

 

[Moomin]

Didn’t see anything against us that was questionable. Think this situation looked worse than it was, it turned out to only be a one handed push and he missed him with the right hand. In no world should a man of that size fall to the floor being pushed with one hand by Jimmy Garner

If we thought the Rohl incident was a pen last week, than this was one as well.

 

[pfim]

If we thought the Rohl incident was a pen last week, than this was one as well.

Why?

 

[Moomin]

Why?

Both had hands on the opponent, if anything the Garner one was probably worse as the ball was in close vicinity.

 

[pfim]

Both had hands on the opponent, if anything the Garner one was probably worse as the ball was in close vicinity.

Garner had one hand on the opponent and wasn’t holding

 

[marsh]

Not why we lost this game but still quite amazing stat

Is this actually true? Ridiculous if it is.
I know City goalie was booked for dissent , I can't remember why the west ham players were booked maybe for dissent or delaying restarts etc.

 

[Moomin]

Garner had one hand on the opponent and wasn’t holding

He blatantly pushed him over

 

[Moomin]

 

[pfim]

View attachment 352971

Look from the opposite side, he missed him with the right hand. Strand Larsen tried to buy one

 

[Moomin]

Look from the opposite side, he missed him with the right hand. Strand Larsen tried to buy one

I thought the Silva one on Rohl was a penalty and this was the same.

 

[ManxBlue]

Silva on Rohl was a certain penalty, Garner’s was a likely penalty.

 

[atrottel]

Unanimous verdict from the Key Incidents Whoever: we should have had a penalty for the foul on Röhl.

That's OK, then we all feel much better, thanks very much, PGMOL.

 

[Lord Byron]

Link here Everton penalty v Man City

 

[terryefc]

17/5/26 Ev 1 Sunderland 3

Grim. Powderpuff players who wilt like stale lettuce.
Ref seemed to let the game be played - unfortunately for us.
Well beaten. No complaints against officials.

Match Officials​

Referee:John Brooks
Video Assistant Referee:Tony Harrington
Assistant Referee 1:Simon Bennett
Assistant Referee 2:Craig Taylor
Fourth Official:Oliver Langford
Assistant VAR Official:Adrian Holmes