Perhaps so, in fairness to him though his second team with us (and best) probably peaked in 09 and was then decimated by cruciate injuries to Arteta Jags Yakubu Anichebe. We then had a horrible financial period of selling Lescott Arteta Yakubu Saha Rodwell and not really getting decent players to replace them culminating in that’s indie where we had Stracqualursi and Drenthe leading the line. If he’d gone at that point we would have been in the dump as what other manager could do anything with that lineup?
In his last few seasons he brought in Jelavic, Gibson, Naismith Mirallas, Oviedo, brought through Barkley, and bought John Stones. It was enough to turn us back into a top 7 club and hand over a decent squad to Martinez. So I never really minded the last few seasons as I thought his rebuilding job was very good to do it so quickly. By that point though I think people had had enough of us never winning at top 4 grounds or in derbies, they were silly stats in my view given what he’d done for the club but they really bothered some people in much the same way that some will never get over to us losing to Newcastle this season.