Top 3 best & worst value for money signings

[zook]

Best:

- Baines ... Left back position sorted with one of the best in the business for 10 years

- Coleman ... Same story as Baines, his peak wasn’t as prolonged but the value for money we got is superb

- Stones ... Signed as an absolute unknown and then went on to make about £45 million profit on him

Worst:

- Sigurdsson
- Bolasie
- Gbamin

I have absolutely nothing against Gbamin and I think he’d have proven to be a good player for us this season, but there’s no way I can’t include him given that he has had more season-ending injuries than he has had starts

 

[Daz1878]

In the Prem era, I think Davie Weir was a great value signing... what did we pay, £250,000 to Hearts? Martyn and Cahill for the other two best value signings.

The worst value ones are much easier to pick out, but I'll go with some more recent ones: Bolasie, Sandro & Schneiderlin.

 

[Lloydystark]

Baines
coleman
Cahill.

siggy
Klaassen
Iwobi

 

[Zezti]

Best:
Coleman - 60 grand etc
Baines - one of the best in his prime
Lukaku - tripled our money and our record PL goal scorer

Worst:
Sigurdsson - 45m of invisible man
Bolasie - 28m of bad stepovers
Klaasen - gone after 1 season for ~12m less

 

[Gilbert..]

Best
Baines
Coleman
Cahill

Worst
Iwobi
Bolasie
Schnederlin

 

[The binman chronicles]

Lukaku
Stones
Lescott

Sandro
Niasse
Bolasie

 

[LouReedwalkonthewildside]

Worst - Sigurdsson, Schneiderlin, Bolaise, Sandro, Klassen.

 

[billyblue80]

Coleman has to be top three when you consider

 

[Amokachi1995]

In the premier league we do well with players with surnames beginning with ‘C’ and badly with those beginning with ‘S’ (the opposite of the 80’s).

 

[Mikey O]

Glenn Keeley - I seem to remember him making his debut in the derby (amybe getting sent off) and us losing 5-0

 

[Kenshin]

Best
Dean
Southall
Coleman

Worst

Siggurdson
Sandro
Van de meyde

Although there is plenty of best for Moyes era

 

[cooperman]

Sandro would be the worst for me, as with his wages, he will have cost us the best part of £20 million and we got a handful of games and 1 goal from him.

What a finish it was though... His first game wasn't it?

Remember thinking at the time how he might play a big part of the season

 

[Aberblue]

Confining it to this century:

Best: Coleman, Stones, Cahill

Worst: Klaassen, Bolasie, Niasse

Heaven knows we could several teams of List no. 2 from the last decade alone.

 

[tommye]

Prem era...
Seamus
Cahill
Tim Howard


Sig
urds
Son

 

[Leylo]

Slaven billic, sandro,sigurdsson koldrop and Beattie all flops