Season Wrap Up

[Kantareller]

Player of the Year - Tim Howard
Young Player of the Year - Ross Barkley.
Surprise Player of the year - John Stones
Most disappointing Player - Leighton Baines
One to watch next season - Aiden McGeady

 

[TheBlueGibbon]

Player Of The Year - McCarthy
Young Player Of The Year - Barkley
Biggest Surprise Player Of The Year - Stones
Most Disappointing Player - Pienaar
One To Watch Next Season - Oviedo

 

[Mikey_Fitzgerald]

Player Of The Year - Seamus Coleman
Young Player Of The Year - Ross Barkley
Biggest Surprise Player Of The Year - Tim Howard (He's been boss!)
Most Disappointing Player - Leighton Baines (Not his best year. Still love him)
One To Watch Next Season - Shane Duffy

Extra category

Man's man award - Tony Hibbert

 

[peteblue]

Player Of The Year - James McCarthy
Young Player Of The Year - Ross Barkley
Biggest Surprise Player Of The Year - Steven Naismith
Most Disappointing Player - Kone
One To Watch Next Season - Messi

 

[aloadofold......]

Playr of the year-------- James McCarthy

Young player................ John Stones

Surprise player............. Steven Naismith

Dissappointing .............. Joel Robles ( really need a # 2 that pushes magnificent Tim)

One to watch................ Lacina Traore

 

[dubfade]

Player Of The Year Coleman
Young Player Of The Year McCarthy
Biggest Surprise Player Of The Year Stones
Most Disappointing Player Gibson (obviously not his fault, but was looking forward to watching him)
One To Watch Next Season Barkley

 

[wm02]

Special recognition to Mirallas for talking us up to Rom

 

[Big Fat Sam]

Player Of The Year: Seamus Coleman
Young Player Of The Year: John Stones
Biggest Surprise Player Of The Year: Steven Naismith
Most Disappointing Player: Leon Osman (have to pick somebody)
One To Watch Next Season: James McCarthy

Edit: Haven't considered any of the injured players to go into the above.

 

[mezzrow]

Player Of The Year - Seamus Coleman - future legend
Young Player Of The Year - Ross (he's boss - on his day...)
Biggest Surprise Player Of The Year - McCarthy (RM was right - it was a bargain)
Most Disappointing Player - Kone (he was awful before he was injured...)
One To Watch Next Season - McGeady - our most accurate passer will be the surprise player of 2014-15

 

[Sarnia Kevin]

Player Of The Year: Seamus Coleman
Young Player Of The Year: John Stones
Biggest Surprise Player Of The Year: Steven Naismith
Most Disappointing Player: None come to mind
One To Watch Next Season: Ross Barkley

 

[Connor]

Player Of The Year -James McCarthy
Young Player Of The Year - Ross Barkley
Biggest Surprise Player Of The Year - Bryan Oviedo
Most Disappointing Player - Steven Pienaar
One To Watch Next Season - John Stones, more games coming his way.

 

[SerenityNigh]

So many of these are hard choices. Not knowing which was your best player in a season is a very good (or very bad) signal.

Player Of The Year
I'll pick Coleman, but it's a fairly even split between him and McCarthy for me.

Young Player Of The Year
Stones has been effortlessly dominant. Barkley has been tremendous too, but even saying such shows how great Stones has been.

Biggest Surprise Player Of The Year
Stones and Naismith.

Most Disappointing Player
For a full season player, Mirallas, but that's relatively harsh. It may be better said that he was one of the few that didn't impress as playing better (maybe my hopes for him were too high). Pienaar has been lacking at times, but he wasn't really disappointing. Kone has shown very little, so he gets a shout as well should Alcaraz.

One To Watch Next Season
I think Stones will be delightful to watch for a long time, and McCarthy could impress all of England as he continues to improve. I think a healthy Gibson add the most excitement at Goodison next season.

 

[mark warner]

POY - McCarthy
YPOY - Sheriff John Stones
BS - The Albino Messi
BD - They've all contributed those who've played
OTW - Tom Cleverly

 

[toffeejack]

Player Of The Year Coleman, although lukaku is our most important
Young Player Of The Year barkley ofc
Biggest Surprise Player Of The Year stones, what a future
Most Disappointing Player kone, poor lad hasn't had time to prove his doubters or his price tag wrong
One To Watch Next Season i'll wait to see our squad

 

[Jacks Dad]

Just a quick thing, like a jarg PFA or something.

From this season alone - pick one Everton player in each category for.

Player Of The Year
Young Player Of The Year
Biggest Surprise Player Of The Year
Most Disappointing Player
One To Watch Next Season

Player of the Season - Coleman, closely followed by McCarthy
Young Player - Ross
Surprise - Naismith
Disappointing - Pienaar, although the first 6 months it was Baines for me.
One to Watch - I hope McAleny but expect McGeady.